PROOF 1.4
DNC MOU Violation

PROOF: Secret Script Subverted MOU with Preferential Nomination

Violation: By using a secret script to impose a pre-arranged slate and provide a preferential nomination to a pre-selected individual, organizers violated the democratic principles of the MOU. This act of favoritism created an unequal and unfair process, subverting the right of all caucuses to genuinely select their representatives and rendering the outcome of the formation meeting illegitimate.
Stakes: By providing a preferential, pre-arranged nomination for one hand-picked individual while sidelining other minority groups, organizers created a two-tiered system that violated the democratic principles of the MOU, ensuring their preferred slate would be installed.
Evidence Strength:
4 facts, 1 axioms

The Axioms (The Rules)

1

The 2020 DNC MOU required that members of the Affirmative Action Committee be 'selected by their particular caucus.' Primary Source

2020-MOU-WVDP-DNC-RBC.pdf, p. 3

Rule Summary

The MOU's requirement that representatives be 'selected by their particular caucus' implies a fair, equal, and democratic process for all caucuses. A system that uses a secret script to impose a pre-arranged slate, including a privileged nomination for one individual, fundamentally violates this principle of fairness.

The Offenses (What Happened)

Selina Vickers circulated a script for the formation meeting with the subject line 'DRAFT SCRIPT - do not share.'

Evidence: selina-script-email.pdf, p. 1 Documentary

The script contained a verbatim sequence for leadership nominations, including 'Mary Ann nominates Hollis Lewis.'

Evidence: selina-script.pdf, p. 1 Official Record

The script also directed a nomination for Kim Felix for the 'at-large diversity seat representing Latino Americans.'

Evidence: selina-script.pdf, p. 3 Official Record

The script did not contain similar at-large nominations for the AAPI or Native American communities, groups the document itself noted were 'missing representation.'

Evidence: selina-script.pdf, p. 2, 5 Official Record

The Logical Reasoning

  1. The MOU requires a fair and democratic selection process for all caucuses.
  2. A secret script with a 'do not share' instruction proves the organizers' intent to control the process undemocratically.
  3. The script dictated the entire leadership slate, making a genuine 'selection' by any caucus impossible.
  4. The preferential nomination for one individual is the clearest example of this rigged, two-tiered system.
  5. The rigged nomination process was fundamentally undemocratic and violated the spirit and letter of the MOU.

Was this page helpful?

Your feedback helps us keep every proof and method page useful.